On November 16, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) proposed a sweeping new rule aimed at fraud in the federal health programs — and one part of it goes straight at a problem Marketplace shoppers have been running into for years: being enrolled in a plan, or switched to a different plan, without their consent.
The proposal is called the CRUSH rule — short for Comprehensive Regulations to Uncover Suspicious Healthcare. CMS estimates the full package would save taxpayers nearly $90 billion over 10 years, at a cost of about $379 million to carry out. Most of the rule covers other federal programs, but the Marketplace section is the one that touches people shopping for coverage right now, in the middle of open enrollment.
What the rule would do to bad-actor agents
Today, CMS can end an agent's or broker's Marketplace agreement after 30 days' notice, or immediately if the agent loses a state license. But under current rules, CMS says it has no authority to shut out an agent or broker because of a felony conviction, or because of past misconduct tied to fraud. The CRUSH proposal would close that gap. Here is what it would change for agents, brokers, and web-brokers on the Marketplace:
- Felony convictions and past misconduct would be grounds to keep someone out. Agents, brokers, and web-brokers with certain felony convictions, or who have been barred from any federally funded health program, could be blocked from Marketplace access.
- Suspension could happen fast. CMS could immediately suspend an agent's Marketplace agreement for up to 90 days based on a credible allegation of abusive conduct that may cause — or is causing — harm to a consumer. The agent would get 30 days to respond and refute the allegation.
- Termination would get easier to prove. CMS would judge terminations for cause on a "preponderance of the evidence" standard, and could terminate an agreement even if the agent fixes the problem within the 30-day window — the current rules let an agent avoid termination by correcting the issue in time.
- No more working the Marketplace from overseas. The rule would write into regulation a ban on agents accessing Marketplace systems from outside the United States — including through a virtual private network (VPN) that routes traffic through another country.
The proposal is explicit that the goal is to reinforce accountability "while supporting the legitimate work of agents and brokers who help Americans find coverage." In other words, the crackdown is aimed at the small number of bad actors, not at the licensed agents who do the work properly.
Why this matters during open enrollment
Unauthorized enrollments and plan switches have been one of the Marketplace's ugliest problems. People have found out — sometimes at the doctor's office, sometimes when a bill arrived — that someone had signed them up for a plan they never chose, or moved them off the plan they had. Announcing the rule, CMS Administrator Dr. Mehmet Oz pointed directly at "signing people up for Marketplace plans without their consent" as one of the schemes the rule is meant to stop. CMS Deputy Administrator Kim Brandt put it in human terms: "Behind every fraudulent claim is a real person: a senior whose identity was stolen, a family switched into a plan they never chose, a patient denied the care they were promised."
That is why the timing matters. Open enrollment for 2027 coverage runs through January 15, with December 15 the deadline for coverage starting January 1. This is the season when enrollment activity — legitimate and otherwise — is at its peak, and when a switch you never asked for can leave you with the wrong doctors, the wrong drug coverage, or a surprise bill in January.
What to do about it
Nothing in the proposal is final yet. It is a proposed rule: CMS is taking public comments until January 19, 2027, and the final version could look different. But the protections shoppers already have are worth using right now:
- Check your own plan. Log in to HealthCare.gov or your state marketplace and confirm the plan listed is the one you picked — and that the agent listed on your account is someone you actually work with.
- Know who is allowed to touch your account. Under the rules that took effect for 2027, your agent needs your authorization once a year, and new shoppers (and anyone switching agents) have to prove their identity before enrolling. Nobody should be making changes to your coverage without your say-so.
- If something changed that you didn't ask for, say so. Contact the Marketplace, and tell your agent. An unauthorized change is not something to shrug off and fix later — it can affect your coverage, your subsidy, and your tax bill.
The bottom line: CMS proposed a rule on November 16 that would give it faster, stronger tools to suspend and bar Marketplace agents and brokers who enroll people or switch their plans without consent — including barring access from outside the country. It's a proposal, not a final rule, and comments are open until January 19, 2027. In the meantime, the smartest move during open enrollment is the simplest one: log in and check that the plan on your account is the plan you chose.
This article is general information, not advice about your specific situation.