Two straight years of double-digit rate hikes are landing hardest on one group: families who earn just enough to get no financial help. A new Commonwealth Fund analysis of 2027 marketplace rate filings warns that households above the subsidy cutoff will "bear the full brunt" of the increases — while everyone else faces a different risk: plans that look cheaper but leave them underinsured.
What's driving the hikes
Rising health care costs are the baseline driver — and analysts expect medical costs to grow faster in 2027 than at any point in nearly two decades. Insurers' filings cite higher provider prices, rising prescription drug costs, more use of services and medications, health care workforce shortages, and general inflation.
On top of that, the marketplace has its own pressures. The enhanced premium tax credits that made coverage far more affordable from 2021 to 2025 expired at the end of 2025. That drove rates up in 2026, and filings show the effects are still compounding in 2027. Marketplace enrollment is expected to drop by 17 to 26 percent, and when younger, healthier people leave, the people who stay are sicker on average and cost more to cover — a cycle that pushes rates higher still.
The middle-income squeeze
Premium tax credits act as a buffer against rate hikes. With the enhanced version gone, that buffer shrank for millions of people with modest incomes — and for millions more, it vanished completely. Individuals earning above roughly $63,840 a year, and families of four above roughly $132,000, get no financial help at all.
The Commonwealth Fund puts it in dollars: a 40-year-old individual earning just above the cutoff who paid $445 per month after tax credits in 2025 could owe $719 per month in 2027. That's a 60% jump with no subsidy to absorb any of it.
The "buy down" trap
When premiums climb, many shoppers do the natural thing: switch to a plan with a lower monthly premium. But those plans almost always come with much higher deductibles — and the analysis warns this could leave more enrollees underinsured: technically covered, but facing bigger barriers to care and more exposure to medical debt.
The math is already moving in that direction. As families have traded down to cheaper plans, average marketplace deductibles have climbed roughly $1,000 in 2026 alone, to nearly $3,800 a year — before the plan pays for much beyond preventive care. A cheap premium with a deductible you can't afford to meet is coverage on paper, not protection in practice.
What to do before Nov 1
- Compare total yearly cost, not just the premium. Premium plus deductible plus copays is the real number — a $50-cheaper premium can cost you thousands more if you use care.
- Check your subsidy position. If your household income sits just above the cutoff (roughly $63,840 for an individual, $132,000 for a family of four), you pay every dollar of the increase — accuracy on your income estimate matters more than ever.
- Don't let sticker shock push you into a plan you can't use. A deductible that stops you from seeing the doctor is not savings. Pick the plan you can actually afford to use.
- Watch your renewal notice. With rates moving and enrollment rules tightening for 2027, auto-renewal can lock you into a worse deal. Review before you click.
The bottom line: the premium is only half the price of your health plan. In a year when the middle of the market absorbs every dollar of the increase, the plan you can afford to use beats the plan you can afford to buy.